Paul Murphy

The Billy Nolan coming off the line thing, because we had quite a few and they're coming in in the comments there, but also I said I'd have a look at the Spotify comments so we don't leave the good Spotify folk out here.

Jason Mullins was in contact straight after the game last night.

Will, when you're having this week's pod, can you ask James about Billy Nolan coming off his line for the penalty save against Cork, did the same against Tipperary?

He's off his line, isn't he?

he is and again we gave Nicky Quaid the hype last week's girl on Billy Nolan like there's an argument that this is an all-star contention even if Waterford don't come out of the group stages it would take almost a miracle for him to qualify now but the way he has played in these first three games he's been incredible

Recent years, I don't know.

I was looking at a few in the 80s particularly, where you could literally be a one and done and you could put in a brilliant performance in an opening game or maybe an opening game in a replay and you could get an All-Star.

It happens less and less now because I think understandably the people who pick this weigh things based on what happens later in the year.

and you can even have someone who shoots the lights out like remember lee chin two years ago where like he had a he was dominant throughout the round robin stage in leinster and you're thinking it's a good chance he could get an all-star here and wexford don't get out of the province and it's just quickly forgotten you pick teams to get from the quarterfinal on like i don't necessarily mind waiting happening later in the championship but like you'd be wrong now at this stage to forget what stephen bennett's done up until this point and what billy nolan has done to this point you know if they're a team that go out early

So there's a committee that come together that create the shortlist and the players vote on player of the year.

five I would say something mad like that but like that was literally I don't think they got past Leinster semi-final that year maybe we have a few shouts from the corner from the comments by the way but also a very fair point made by David Curley before we forget the penalties what about forwards who foul the ball by going over the 21 before striking the ball yeah absolutely yeah 100% we said it's Hejo against Hejo in the league final yeah same case it's the exact same case but yeah yeah yeah

And I would agree with some people who've said as well that really the goalkeeper should be allowed to start marching once the ball has been addressed, once it's been picked up.

At that point, the goalkeeper should be allowed to go at it.

No, it was a weird year, but at the same time, that's a good one where it was very early on.

And Mike has also pointed out that John Lave Tip won an All-Star without playing in the Championship.

What?

Hard to see it happening again.

Apparently, he shot the lights out in the league that year.

jeez now that's a fair call yeah that was back in that's definitely late 80s early 90s come back at this mic with exactly what year it is but I remember that being mentioned a few years ago that's remarkable hmm do you know fantastic really Eamon wants to know let's go to the other goalkeeper then interest to get Scales sick on Patrick Collins performance at the weekend I thought he was excellent against Waterford sorry what I was thinking about there when I saw the name Patrick Collins some guy came at me during the week saying why do you just like Patrick Collins so much I was like

I guess that came in a second.