Payton Moreland
speaker
3,581 appearances
30 recordings
1 series
first heard Nov 2024
last heard Jun 2025
Payton Moreland’s voice in public audio — every appearance, attributed to the second.
Trend
recordings per month · last 12 monthsNo recordings in the last 12 months.Older appearances are listed below; set an alert to hear about the next one.
Appearances
That reusable grocery bag with Kelly's purse and wallet, the one that Sheila's sons said their mom led them to, the police can't find it anywhere.
Sie sagt, nein, ich denke, es ist nur ein Traum. Aber als sie ihren nervösen Ausbruch hatte, gab sie die Möglichkeit.
Ja, also bringen sie sie in. Und tatsächlich, das wird wirklich schnell gehen. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Die ganze Sache ist unglaublich bizarr, weil es war, ich meine, die Polizei hätte sie nicht sogar gespürt. Es gab nichts, was sie anzeigte. Aber jetzt sind die Polizei-Figuren, sie sind das Beste, was sie haben.
Well, they're going to say that she confessed, essentially.
I was going to say, that's not going to hold up in court. Right, she was having a nervous breakdown.
But then also you tell a jury, well, she led us right to the body. Yeah. That's a little suspicious as well. So not only is she facing first degree murder charges for killing her soon to be ex-husband's girlfriend, who was also her friend. She's also denied bail. So Sheila Trott sits behind bars for four and a half years. Whoa. Awaiting her trial. And the entire time she insists, she's innocent.
She's like, I was just freaking out. I really did just have a dream. I did not do this.
She's denied bail. So you can't get out while you're prepping for trial. And it's just kind of up, it's just case to case about who gets denied bail and who doesn't.
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure no, because that is just the way the justice system works. Even though you were found not guilty, it still took... The proper channels of you building a defense.
But also you.
Okay, but you have a right to a speedy trial.
What I'm saying is, I think technically her defense could have said, no, we need to go to trial now, even if the state wasn't ready.
But they must not have. Something happened. They must have been trying to build a defense as well.
So, she's like, I'm innocent the whole time. As soon as she gets arrested, she says, I'm innocent. And because of this, she doesn't take a plea deal. She had took a deal. She probably would have been, it wouldn't have taken four years. She waits until September of 2014 for her day in court.
Now, the defense feels pretty confident at the very least that they have a good case for at least some reasonable doubt. As I mentioned, there's practically nothing in a way of physical evidence against Sheila. But the prosecution paints a convincing narrative for the jury of what they believed happened that night at trial. And this is what they say.
On the evening of February 15th, back in 2010, Sheila left her house sometime between 6 to 7 p.m. telling her sons she was making a trip to Walmart. But that was a total lie. Instead, Sheila went to Kelly Brennans house, waited in her yard, and as Kelly was leaving, she snuck up behind her, ambushed her, and attacked her from behind.
Likely with a hammer for the autopsy, even though no weapon was ever found. And Kelly never saw it coming. They suggested that Sheila then put Kelly in her own car and drove the 13 miles to Mark's Landing, where she left her body, and then drove back to Caddo Court, parked Kelly's car there, before making the half a mile walk back to her own car that was still parked at Kelly's house.
Now, part of this narrative is based on two things that they found in Kelly Brennans yard. A drag mark and blood seemingly leading to Kelly's vehicle. So this is where they believe the initial attack happened, was at Kelly's home. But the defense... Yeah, uh-huh. This was in the front yard.
Not to mention that blood found in Kelly's yard that police believe was the evidence showing that it happened there. Only one sample of that blood was collected and sent to a lab during the investigation and when they ran it against Kelly's blood, it came back negative.
Was die Polizei nicht getestet hat, war das Blut, das neben Kellys Körper auf Marks Landing gefunden wurde. Die Verteidigung sagte, das sei nur schade Polizistische Arbeit, weil das Blut von einem Attaker sein könnte. Und ihr habt es nie getestet, also könnt ihr nicht beweisen, ob es nicht mein Klient war.
Showing 1921–1940 of 3,581 · page 97 of 180
← Previous
Next →