Peter Tragos

She was a single woman dating a law enforcement officer, had a great job in finance, and her family was a close-knit family, loved each other for all intents and purposes.

When she reconnected with this boyfriend who was an officer and they go out for a night on the town, they had a bit of a tumultuous relationship.

And then that night after some drinking at the bar, hanging out with a bunch of friends, everything changed forever.

Yeah, I mean, it turns on what happened after they got to 34 Fairview.

Everybody's basically on the same page.

They went to a couple bars.

They were hanging out together.

They were drinking together.

Karen Reed is driving her Lexus.

Nobody disputes that.

John O'Keefe, who was her boyfriend and the victim in this case, sitting in the front seat.

They drive to 34 Fairview to hang out with the McCabes and the Alberts, who are all connected to law enforcement and connected to people in Canton.

She drops him off.

He gets out of the car.

There also seems to be third party witness testimony that he gets out of the car.

After that, that's where the stories kind of turn.

If you believe the prosecution and the witnesses inside 34 Fairview, he never makes it inside the house.

She backs up, hits him with her Lexus because she's angry at him about, you know, a multitude of things and they're fighting and.

She wanted to end his life, I guess, is their point of view.

If you believe Karen Reid, she said he walked in towards the house.