Peter Tragos

So this taillight, there was so much litigation about this taillight.

First, the defense says there was a video that shows she backed up very slowly into John O'Keefe's car at John O'Keefe's house.

And that's how she cracked her taillight and there was just a little crack in it.

Not when she hit John O'Keefe.

The prosecution says, no, it was totally damaged, destroyed, and they had in 46 different pieces.

But what made the taillight so interesting is it was towed to the sally port where law enforcement is.

And when they tried to show when the SUV was dropped off, they showed an inverted video, a flipped video.

And they were like, hey, nobody even went near this taillight.

But then when you realize it's a flipped video, which they did in the middle of trial.

Then you realize there are people that walk by that taillight.

And when you look closer at the entire time it was in the sally port, there are blips and cuts in and out and huge chunks of time missing where you don't see what's going on with that Lexus.

And the defense said, well, where are those chunks?

And the Commonwealth says, well, you know, it's motion activated, so it might not be there.

And then when they secured the crime scene the first day, they found a couple pieces of taillight in the yard, right, where John O'Keefe's body was found.

But days and weeks and months went by and they continued to find taillight piece after taillight piece after taillight piece in this front yard that they didn't find the first time they went, the second time they went, the third time they went.

They just happened to be driving by and they'd find another piece of taillight, very sketchy, unlike just about every investigation you've probably ever seen.

So they're implying that they would go back to the yard, put the pieces in the yard after they busted it at the sally port, and they would find it every day, more and more pieces of taillight that they didn't find the first day, the first week.

And they just kept planting pieces of taillight and going and getting it to make sure there are text message that said, we're going to pin it on the girl.

And we're going to make sure that nobody in the house catches any crap.

We're going to make sure he's a Boston cop.