Peter Tragos

That's a quote from the text messages.

And they would talk about how she had a balloon knot because she had some, you know, surgery or issues, gastro internal issues.

They would talk about how she had leaky poo.

They would talk about how she, you know, some of the text messages with

the person that she was having the affair with were back and forth and racy and talking about john and how we need to hide this from john and then that person went to the police station that night at 2 a.m and said he was moving cars around but was instead moving bags back and forth between different cars going inside the police station with his hood up and just sketchy thing on top of sketchy thing from all these law enforcement officers involved

You know, it's really hard for me to say, like beyond a reasonable doubt, I don't think either side would ever be able to prove this.

And because of that, and because the investigation was so horrible, and I just don't feel like I can trust anything the cops say or did in this case, you'd never get a conviction.

This is a case I would never want to try.

I prosecuted cases.

I would never prosecute this case.

This is just not one I would have felt ethically comfortable with putting in front of a jury.

On the civil side, will they be able to get enough to prove to a jury by the greater weight of the evidence, 51%?

I think it's possible, but it's just so hard to know what happened inside that house of 34 Fairview.

So if I had to choose, is she factually innocent or is she factually guilty, I would choose that she's factually innocent.

I'm just not overly confident of that.

I don't think I would be able to say that

beyond a reasonable doubt, because I really don't think anybody's ever going to be able to prove what happened that night.

Yeah, it's brutal to think about the victim's family in this.

The O'Keeffe's and all of this, regardless of what happened and who did what inside 34 Fairview or law enforcement, they lost John O'Keeffe and that family has gone through, I don't know if you know any of the backstory of that family.

They have gone through