Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz

That seems to be a machlokas in the Chacham Tzvi, as a chuvon, some peydalid, where he talks about a behim asnachri, that a guy was Boel, that it's ne'ereges b'din yachin, and it's a surah,

because of that because they can have a misas abaylim kach misas ashar and the Chacham Shvi discusses both sides of that issue so that is an unresolved dispute whether you can have a misas ashar when it comes to without the benefit of a Sanhedrin another point to consider

is that the Minchashinuk writes that if a Nachri is chayiv in Dinim like a Yisrael, then a shor shal Nachri shaharag is chayiv skila.

But if you assume like the Rambam in Niskay Mamon, parakira lacha alef, that while it's true that Nachrim have an obligation of implementing Dinim, but they don't have to implement our Dinim, and Shor Aniskel is not one of the Dinim that they need to implement.

The Rambam writes that a shah who kills anybody is Ne'erag, but if it kills a guy, it's Potter.

So the Pashtos of the Rambam, Menchashinuch learns it otherwise, but the Pashtos of the Rambam is because the Din of Sharan Iskal is not one of the Dine B'nei Nowach.

And therefore the whole idea that a Nachri shah is going to become a Sharan Iskal may not be accurate.

So maybe it doesn't become a Sharan Iskal anyway.

And then another point to consider is that even if

you could be Dan Yechidi and therefore Kamis HaBanu Mekah Kamis HaShar so it could become a Sharan Yisrael and even if the Dinam of Sharan Yisrael apply to Bnei Noach they're not excluded but maybe you actually need a Gemara Din in order to make it Aser Ba'ana maybe it doesn't become Aser Ba'ana automatically it's only after a Gemara Din Rabbeinu Taim and Sefer HaYosha writes that it's only after a Gemara Din

And not only after a Gemardin, it's only after the Maisa Skelah.

It's only after you actually kill it, then it becomes Aser Ba'ana.

The Rambam writes that it's after the Gemardin it's Aser Ba'ana, and others suggest that maybe less, maybe even before the Gemardin, maybe like the Nachash, that you can kill it right away.

Maybe that's an indication that it's Aser Ba'ana right away.

At the end of the day, everyone who wrote about this was Meikil.

You're allowed to go to the biblical zoo, you can see the leopard, and the reason is that first of all, maybe seeing isn't Hana'a.

And even if seeing Yitzhanah, maybe a shor shanach, a shor yisrael, is not nerag to begin with, so it's not asr banah.

And then even if you say that a shor is chayiv, it's only going to be bifnei chav gimel, and not less of a bezid.

And even if you say that it's nidon b'yachid, maybe that's only if it's actually nidon, but if it was never nidon, it never becomes a shor niskel, and then may you're allowed to go visit the zoo.

Okay, everyone have a great day.