Sam Edmund

Yeah, so that's the majority view.

I think, and so well admired and respected for the way that he's gone about it.

But what will his legacy be in 10 years' time as a leader?

He's played in four finals.

Well, that's the question.

Is it not his fault, or do we just say it's not his fault?

Why is it not his fault?

Four finals as the superstar of this club.

Yep, individually, no worries.

205 Brownlow medal votes, for goodness sake.

But it's about winning.

He's played in four finals in the whole of his career.

He's 31 now.

Look, he's clearly well past his best.

But how will Carlton fans remember Patrick Cripps is the question.

So you think there's been more scrutiny on Cripps and you think it's been unfair?

Yeah.

Because I think he's been lauded myself.

Rarely have we ever criticised Patrick Cripps for obvious reasons.

No, I'm not saying it's not all his fault, but when you look at the majority of his, when you look at his body of work in 10 years' time, you've got, well, amazing individually.