Steve Tuck

Or maybe that was this year.

And I think like that got, that, that got like, obviously that got retweeted from a bunch of folks because a bunch of folks feel that way with that, that their offering was becoming an AWS offering.

But I don't think people realize like, no, no, I was talking about oxide.

That was an oxide subtweet.

We literally didn't have a name for the company.

And Amazon had already killed it with Outposts.

But I had a bunch of questions about like, is it rented or owned?

I think it's going to be rented, but they didn't, you know, this was by 2018, reInvent had changed.

It used to be like, you know, reInvent announces something and Jeff Barr is demoing it on stage and you can provision on it right now.

And it was just, they were such killers.

And I think by 2018, that was starting to fade.

And like now we're actually kind of like putting things on stage that actually aren't available yet.

Oh, by the way, we don't have any details on this.

And there's kind of some stagecraft to it and blah, blah, blah, blah.

But we, the full economic analysis, Adam, I don't think, I mean, I think you were one of the first ones to really take it apart.

Is that, I think that's right.

And you were digging into it in part because I'm going to prove to everyone that Oxide is doomed.

I mean, is that being too reductive?

Maybe that's being too reductive.

Right.