In this bonus episode, Sara and Andrea sit down to revisit the first two cases from Season 2 of SEQUESTERED: the disappearances of Tonetta Carlisle and Brandy Hall. With fresh eyes and honest questions, they unpack what still doesn’t sit right—from the mysterious witnesses in Tonetta’s case to the conflicting theories around Brandy’s final hours. Why did key players lie? What evidence might still be waiting in an old file or forgotten bag? And who, after all these years, still knows something but hasn’t come forward? This is a deeper dive into what haunts us, what’s missing, and why these open cases still matter. Send us your thoughts at [email protected]

Ask this episode

“What did the council decide on item 42?” — answered with the speaker and the moment.