Brendan Sorsby Tried to Use the NFL as an Escape Hatch. Roger Goodell Said No. Get up to $200 off Square hardware when you sign up at square.com/go/WINGO #squarepod #sponsored Head to cozyearth.com and use code WINGO for an exclusive 20% off. Go to https://kachava.com and use code WINGO for 15% off your first order. This is the latest chapter in the Brendan Sorsby saga — and it may be the most important one yet. For those catching up — Brendan Sorsby is a college quarterback who started at Indiana, transferred to Cincinnati, and then had his entire world unravel when the full scope of his gambling problem became public. We are not talking about a few casual bets. We are talking about thousands of bets placed on his own team, on teammates, on other sports, using intermediaries to avoid detection, potentially violating state criminal law. A sustained, systematic pattern of behavior that broke every rule in place to protect the integrity of athletic competition. The NCAA banned him. A judge in Lubbock, Texas — home of Texas Tech — granted him an injunction to play anyway. The NCAA appealed. The injunction was overturned. Sorsby then tried a different escape route — the NFL supplemental draft. Enter the league, get drafted, collect a paycheck, and sidestep the consequences of everything that happened in college. Roger Goodell and the NFL just said no. The league announced it will not hold a supplemental draft this summer. A letter was sent to Sorsby and all 32 teams. Brendan Sorsby's only path to the NFL is now the 2027 Annual Draft — and even that is far from guaranteed given everything the league knows about what he did. Why the NFL Was Right The NFL's position on gambling is about as clear as anything in professional sports. The rules have been explicit since the league became formally intertwined with legal sports betting after the Supreme Court opened that door. Bet on any NFL game — minimum one year suspension. Bet on your own team — minimum two years. Share inside information — minimum one year. Use someone else to place a bet — minimum one year. Fix a game — lifetime ban. Now look at what Sorsby did. Thousands of bets. On his own team. Using intermediaries to place them. At three different universities. The NFL looked at that record and made a simple determination — this is not someone who gets to use our league as an escape hatch from the consequences of his actions. The line between the NFL's business relationships with sports books and casinos and its players actually gambling is not a gray area. It is one of the clearest lines in professional sports. And the NFL has been consistent about enforcing it. The league's association with legal sports gambling actually makes it smarter about detecting unusual betting patterns — that is one of the arguments for having it, as Trey explains. When a match gets fixed or something irregular happens, the betting data shows it. The NFL is not going to let someone with Sorsby's record walk through the front door and compromise that integrity infrastructure. Jeffrey Kessler Is Wrong on Both Counts Sorsby's attorney Jeffrey Kessler went to ESPN immediately after the announcement and declared that the NFL's decision is — quote — a violation of the CBA and the law. He is wrong on both counts. Let Trey explain why. First — Brendan Sorsby is not an NFL player. He is not a member of the NFL Players Association. The CBA governs the relationship between the NFL and its players. Sorsby has no standing under the CBA because he has no relationship with the league as a player. You cannot invoke a collective bargaining agreement that does not apply to you. Second — the CBA gives the NFL complete and total autonomy over whether to hold a supplemental draft in any given year. It is entirely the league's discretion. It is not mandatory. It is not guaranteed. The league has not held a supplemental draft since 2019. They were not planning to hold one this year before Sorsby filed his petition three business days before the deadline, without supporting documentation, and only after abandoning his litigation against the NCAA. The NFL's letter makes all of this explicit. So Jeffrey Kessler's argument is that the NFL violated a CBA that does not apply to his client by exercising a discretion that the CBA explicitly grants them. That is not a legal argument. That is a press release. And then comes the part that makes this argument even more confusing — if your goal is to get your client drafted by the NFL, threatening to sue the NFL is a spectacularly counterproductive opening move. Even if Kessler somehow found legal footing — which he will not — all the NFL has to do is not draft him. Proving that amounts to collusion would be nearly impossible. The NFL does not need to give anyone a reason for not selecting them in a draft. The Deflate Gate Precedent Trey makes the legal argument with the clearest possible parallel — Deflate Gate. Whether or not Tom Brady and the Patriots actually deflated those footballs — and Trey believes they did, given that the equipment manager's nickname was literally The Deflator — does not matter for the legal question. The Patriots and Brady mounted a legitimate scientific argument about PSI changes due to weather conditions. It was a real argument. And it did not matter. The reason Brady served his four-game suspension had nothing to do with whether balls were actually deflated. It had everything to do with a single clause in the CBA — the one that grants Roger Goodell the authority to adjudicate matters of competitive integrity. Brady and the NFLPA had agreed to that clause. The court upheld it. The suspension stood. The Sorsby situation is legally identical. The CBA grants the NFL complete discretion over the supplemental draft. There is no appeal. There is no workaround. There is no legal theory that overrides it. Commissioner Bigfoot put his foot down and the law is on his side. What Comes Next Sorsby now needs to find somewhere to play football to keep his skills sharp and his professional prospects alive. The CFL is a possibility. There may be other options. But the NFL in 2026 is not one of them. The 2027 NFL Draft is theoretically available to him — but the league will be watching everything between now and then. His gambling history, his pattern of attempting to avoid consequences through litigation rather than accountability, and his attorney's opening move of threatening to sue the league he wants to play in — none of that is going to make the conversation any easier when 2027 arrives. Trey makes something clear that is worth repeating. He is not rooting against Brendan Sorsby as a person. He genuinely hopes Sorsby gets the help he needs and addresses the gambling problem that has derailed his career. If he does the work, demonstrates real accountability, and earns his way into the NFL through the proper process — fine. But the idea that he can circumvent consequences by jumping from one venue to the next, finding the most favorable judge available, and threatening to sue anyone who tries to enforce a rule — that approach was always going to hit a wall eventually. Roger Goodell is that wall. Commissioner Bigfoot has spoken. And those are straight facts, homie. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Ask this episode

“What did the council decide on item 42?” — answered with the speaker and the moment.

Transcript

Related