Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing
Podcast Image

The Journal.

The Shakeup Coming for Car Dealerships

28 May 2026

Transcription

Chapter 1: What challenges are traditional car dealerships facing today?

5.583 - 10.954 Jessica Mendoza

When you head southeast out of Phoenix, Arizona, what you'll see is mostly empty space.

0

13.398 - 28.047 Christopher Otts

You're driving through just miles and miles of essentially desert. There's like cactuses and just a clear sky, and it's very remote.

0

28.87 - 41.168 Jessica Mendoza

Our colleague Chris Otts made that trip recently to the small town of Casa Grande. Chris covers the auto industry, and he was on his way to a sleepy car dealership out in the desert that had caught his interest.

0

42.15 - 51.443 Christopher Otts

It's pretty small. There's a few people inside. There's a few people waiting on their cars to be serviced. There's a few mechanics out back.

0

53.667 - 59.45 Jessica Mendoza

For years, this dealership sold maybe a few dozen cars a month. But now?

60.332 - 66.403 Christopher Otts

This particular store is now doing about 350 sales a month.

69.108 - 92.053 Jessica Mendoza

Those skyrocketing sales have taken place over the last year, ever since the store was taken over by a new owner, Carvana, a company most known for selling used cars online. But Carvana is now bringing its modern approach to car sales into the new car business. And the dealership in Casa Grande is early proof of success.

94.447 - 102.742 Jessica Mendoza

Chris says this new kind of dealership might be a sign of big changes coming to the car sales industry, which has stayed pretty much the same for decades.

103.543 - 129.777 Christopher Otts

And right now we're seeing a number of different challenges to that model. Companies that are trying to offer a different experience today. I just see the car dealership model generally as a really well-built fortress. And now there's an incursion on the outside of the fortress walls, you know, trying to get in.

Chapter 2: How has Carvana changed the car buying experience?

434.297 - 456.183 Christopher Otts

Dealers, for the most part, have been the only source for new vehicles. And Even though it's so incredibly common to hear people complain about not liking the experience, if you want a new car, there really isn't much alternative.

0

457.004 - 474.358 Jessica Mendoza

At least, not until the mid-2000s, when a new company brought its EVs to market, Tesla. Instead of creating its own dealership network, Tesla decided to sell directly to consumers. Even though that was illegal in many states, the company forged ahead anyway.

0

475.719 - 490.155 Christopher Otts

So they had battles state by state to win the ability to sell directly to consumers. Lots of lawsuits, lots of administrative proceedings before state commissions and such.

0

490.395 - 494.64 Unknown

Tesla and other EV makers asked for the right to sell directly to customers.

0

495.11 - 498.395 Christopher Otts

and by and large, they've won that fight.

498.736 - 512.697 Unknown

Unlike other auto companies that use franchise dealers, Tesla sells its cars directly to consumers. The company will be allowed to do direct sales from its Cincinnati, Columbus, and Cleveland showrooms.

513.436 - 539.224 Jessica Mendoza

In the end, Tesla was able to get carve-outs in many states that allowed it to sell directly to consumers. But in some states, Tesla is allowed to do this because it only sells EVs. And in some places, it has to follow other constraints too, like not having salespeople. Tesla proved that a car company could sell direct to consumer. Now, the only place you can buy a new Tesla is from Tesla.

540.084 - 542.447 Jessica Mendoza

And this approach has started to catch on.

542.562 - 553.906 Christopher Otts

So there are other new EV players who have come on the scene, Rivian, Lucid. They are also going direct to consumer, making the same choice that Tesla did.

Chapter 3: Why do consumers dislike the traditional dealership experience?

1137.603 - 1142.853 Jessica Mendoza

Are they running out of gas? Is the check engine light on? Is there a better car metaphor that we could use here?

0

1142.893 - 1164.038 Christopher Otts

Yeah. I think in a lot of ways, change is here. Basically, the forces of digital and e-commerce keep trying to breach these gates. But yeah, I do think it's way too early to ring the bell on

0

1164.018 - 1191.848 Christopher Otts

traditional car dealerships and they will tell you that they think that a lot of people still do want to touch and feel the car in person right and that they're working on ways to make it like a less intimidating experience some have different sales models you know some don't have commissioned salespeople like there there are experiments out there but the degree to which this system can be breached is really the question

0

1202.442 - 1219.05 Jessica Mendoza

That's all for today, Thursday, May 28th. The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal. If you like our show, follow us on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. We're out every weekday afternoon. Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.

0
Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.