Excessive Fines Clause

authority
6 mentions 4 recordings first heard Feb 2015 last heard 8 Oct ↓3 vs the 6 months before

Statutory clause limiting fines to proportionality with the offense

Trend

mentions per week · public audio 7d30d6M12M
No mentions in the last 6M.Widen the range to see when Excessive Fines Clause was said.

Moments

newest first · ▶ plays the moment
Carol A. CorriganSupreme Court of California · Supreme Court Oral Argument 2025-10 -08 - Oct 08, 2025 · 5:06:11 · 8 Oct
…And that's controlled by the excessive fines and fees clause.…
· Open transcript →
Joshua A. KleinSupreme Court of California · Supreme Court Oral Argument 2025-10 -08 - Oct 08, 2025 · 4:55:02 · 8 Oct
…Under the excessive fines clause, the effect that a given fine has on a particular defendant is a factor, and their limited means is a factor in determining whether that fine is grossly disproportionate punishment.…
· Open transcript →
Leondra R. KrugerSupreme Court of California · Supreme Court Oral Argument 2025-10 -08 - Oct 08, 2025 · 4:32:14 · 8 Oct
…So when we're talking about the excessive fines clause, right, we're looking at the culpability of the defendant, the seriousness of the offense, the fines and fees or whatever penalties that are imposed for other similar crimes.…
· Open transcript →
UnknownSupreme Court of the United States · Tyler v. Hennepin County (22-166) · 54:26 · Apr 2023
…And this Court has only addressed the excessive fines clause……
Mr. HodditSupreme Court of the United States · Timbs v. Indiana (17-1091) · 0:06 · Nov 2018
…Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court, the……
Mr. OrtizSupreme Court of the United States · Henderson v. United States (13-1487) · 15:44 · Feb 2015
…There are excessive fine clause issues.…
6 moments · sign in to read them all