Lindsay Farley

…Lindsay immediately started her nine-hour car drive to the Guse home in Chafont, California. After getting off of the phone with Lindsay, Zach then called the police to report Carly as missing. Police showed up to the house a few hours later, and when they looked around, they noticed that there was no sign of a struggle or foul play.…

…Zach and Melissa continued to search for Carly, but they went back home at around 9 30 because they just could not find her. This was when Zach called Lindsay and told her that Carly was gone. He basically said that she just went to a party and now she's gone. She kept asking him all of these questions and he's like, I don't know, she just went to a party a…

…However, they apparently gave this recording to Lindsay's private investigator and that's when Lindsay actually heard this recording. Lindsay claims that Carly was begging Melissa to call 911, but that Melissa was refusing. But Melissa came back and said that this wasn't true. According to Melissa, Carly said, if something were to happen, would you call 911…