Tom Finley

…Susan had started dating someone else too, Tom Finley, a coworker at that textile company. But with the boys missing, David knew he had to be there to support his wife any way he could.…

…And Tom, he obviously had no idea any of this was going on. So he finally, once and for all, just ends it with Susan. It is over. Here's the thing though. Tom said it's over. But what Susan hears is maybe we have a chance. So that night, Susan comes up with a wild plan to try and win Tom Finley back. Now in that letter he had sent her, Tom mentions that he…

…Now, Susan, at this point, she's really upset, because she's super in love with Tom. And she doesn't take this letter well, and she is determined to win him back. So, one day, she shows up to visit him at work, and she's a total wreck. And she's crying, and for some reason, she confesses to him that she hooked up with her former stepdad. Ew. And she tells h…