Brett M. Kavanaugh
speaker
21,539 appearances
451 recordings
1 series
first heard Jan 2018
last heard 29 Apr
Brett M. Kavanaugh’s voice in public audio — every appearance, attributed to the second.
Trend
recordings per month · last 12 monthsRecordings per month over the last 12 months — 53 in all, peaking in Mar 2026 with 10.
Appearances
And so Congress looking at this area
podcast-host
The idea that state tort law is going to regulate what goes on in Bagram, I think Congress would be like, hmm, sounds
podcast-host
Way out there uh and not something that they need to get involved in because of the doctrine, as as Crosby says, that is de t dependently applied.
podcast-host
contractors, though.
podcast-host
Especially through a federal.
podcast-host
I mean, there's been a lot of discussion in the case law about how you distinguish field and conflict, but uh you know, field preemption in an area of uniquely federal interest, uh you know, you can call it conflict, you can call it field, but the word field has been in our case law at times on this kind of thing.
podcast-host
I'll stop there, but I want to get that comment.
podcast-host
based on choice of law principles?
podcast-host
I you know, i it's certainly possible, Your Honor.
podcast-host
So it is possible that a a suit against a military con contractor at a in a war zone could be based on the enemy's law.
podcast-host
Can I circle back to something Justice Alito asked?
podcast-host
And you said yes, I believe, but correct me if I'm wrong.
podcast-host
And I wanted to know is uniquely federal interest a branch of constitutional preemption in your view?
podcast-host
We believe it's it's a branch of federal common law preemption, Your Honor.
podcast-host
What's the difference then between what you're calling constitutional preemption and federal common law preemption as to the concept of uniquely federal interest or is there any difference at all?
podcast-host
Unless Congress specifies otherwise, always important to put that on there.
podcast-host
Congress could provide for state tort law in this area.
podcast-host
That's m that's my point, which is
podcast-host
This whole whole case in my view starts with what's your baseline with state tort law regulating military contractors in a war zone.
podcast-host
Is your baseline that Congress has to speak to displace that or that Congress has to speak to provide for that?
podcast-host
Showing 2761–2780 of 21,539 · page 139 of 1077
← Previous
Next →