Lieutenant Robert Young
speaker
54 appearances
2 recordings
1 series
first heard Feb 2025
last heard Mar 2025
Lieutenant Robert Young’s voice in public audio — every appearance, attributed to the second.
Trend
recordings per month · last 12 monthsNo recordings in the last 12 months.Older appearances are listed below; set an alert to hear about the next one.
Appearances
He had a girlfriend who lived in Mexico and they tried to talk to her. And then they tried to talk to his former employees. And they said, you're allowed to what they call pouch. And that's transfer things across the border without paying a duty tax on them. He would always come to his co-workers and go, hey, take this across the border for me.
And people felt like they were being imposed upon by him, and it was getting to the point where they felt it was uncomfortable, you know. So people weren't really speaking highly of him to the detectives.
Now, I feel that if I don't die a natural death, it's possible Jim would have found a convoluted solution to his own dilemma. How to control all assets by removing Carol. A final solution not unlike he judged his father to have dealt with his own mother. A pillow over her face. Supposedly, there were allegations that his father put a pillow over his wife's face.
Carol spoke, you know, the whole divorce caused her a lot of stress emotionally, financially as well. James, you know, near the end of their marriage, in addition to seeing other women, she had asked him to leave before. There was no indication he was physically abusive. There was indication he was verbally abusive. There was indications he may have done inappropriate things with his daughter.
That really was brought to Carol's attention, and I think that was the final straw. She had dealt with verbal abuse for a while. Jim was very domineering, and I think once this issue between the daughter and her husband surfaced, I think that caused her to say, this is it. She went to stay in the condo in Naples, Florida and initiated divorce proceedings.
And obviously those dragged on for over three years.
The night of the homicide, Carlos doesn't get to work till midnight. Virginia said she decided to go out shopping at 11 p.m. And Virginia says she goes to the ATM, takes some cash out, and says she wanted to go get some groceries and maybe cook something for Carlos before he got to work.
Like, how is there a long line at 11.30? Then they said the computer was down. It would only take five minutes. I was looking at the clock and I was going to be late. So she paid cash and got home and it was too late to make him a meal because he has to leave at 11.45 to get to work at midnight. So that never really panned out and the detectives at the time found her actions suspicious.
They knew the divorce settlement maybe was coming up because they didn't have that much money. Maybe she could take her mom's place and be the benefactor of all this divorce settlement and gain that money. So there was that angle that was looked at. They're both working blue-collar jobs trying to make ends meet. So yeah, the money that they could have gained, that's always a motive.
Sergeant Johnson, he's this polygraph guy, he's doing the pre-interview, he asked Carlos if he drove Carol's vehicle from the condo right after she was murdered. His initial response was, yes.
So then Sergeant Johnson gives him the polygraph. He stated Carlos showed deception and was not being truthful. So they do a post-interview, and Carlos could not explain why he was not telling the truth. He agreed to return at 9 a.m. the following day to take another polygraph. Carlos showed up the next day to take the polygraph again. He showed he was being deceptive and not telling the truth.
Carlos did not confess. Carlos stated the polygraph was not working right, and detectives at the scene screwed it up. Carlos voluntarily provided an oral swab for DNA, and then he was permitted to leave. So Carlos tells Virginia what happened during the interview.
The hair did not contain roots. One hair looked like a brown hair, like a body hair. The other hair looked like a grayish hair. And so I presented this to DNA Labs International, and they said, save that for your Hail Mary, because... Technology is not really there yet as far as just doing the stock without a route, but hold on to it.
So they looked at it and they said, let's look at some other items.
Showing 41–54 of 54 · page 3 of 3
← Previous