Mouin Rabbani

Um, I also think, um, that we can both agree that this had never been an issue prior to Zionism and the emergence of the state of Israel. Look, I'm, I'm not, didn't begin with Zionism in the Arab world. The issue is, is, is, is the point I raised, which is whether these communities had ever come to a collective conclusion that they're, position had become untenable in this part of the world.

Um, I also think, um, that we can both agree that this had never been an issue prior to Zionism and the emergence of the state of Israel. Look, I'm, I'm not, didn't begin with Zionism in the Arab world. The issue is, is, is, is the point I raised, which is whether these communities had ever come to a collective conclusion that they're, position had become untenable in this part of the world.

Um, I also think, um, that we can both agree that this had never been an issue prior to Zionism and the emergence of the state of Israel. Look, I'm, I'm not, didn't begin with Zionism in the Arab world. The issue is, is, is, is the point I raised, which is whether these communities had ever come to a collective conclusion that they're, position had become untenable in this part of the world.

No, they were Arab Jews.

No, they were Arab Jews.

No, they were Arab Jews.

It wasn't the Jews of England or the Soviet Jews. I think it's useful to refer to Zionists before 1948 and Israelis after 1948.

It wasn't the Jews of England or the Soviet Jews. I think it's useful to refer to Zionists before 1948 and Israelis after 1948.

It wasn't the Jews of England or the Soviet Jews. I think it's useful to refer to Zionists before 1948 and Israelis after 1948.

Yeah, from Morocco. Avishlaim from Iraq has written on this issue.

Yeah, from Morocco. Avishlaim from Iraq has written on this issue.

Yeah, from Morocco. Avishlaim from Iraq has written on this issue.

I think it's more complex than that. I think it was... Sorry, I interrupted you.

I think it's more complex than that. I think it was... Sorry, I interrupted you.

I think it's more complex than that. I think it was... Sorry, I interrupted you.

That's indisputable.

That's indisputable.

That's indisputable.

I'll make two points. The first is, you mentioned Haj Amin al-Husseini and his collaboration with the Nazis. entirely legitimate point to raise, but I think one can also say definitively had Hajj Amin al-Husseini never existed, the Holocaust would have played out precisely as it did.

I'll make two points. The first is, you mentioned Haj Amin al-Husseini and his collaboration with the Nazis. entirely legitimate point to raise, but I think one can also say definitively had Hajj Amin al-Husseini never existed, the Holocaust would have played out precisely as it did.