Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz

Rabbi Willig does it for rabbis.

for i think uh a national council of young israel for for rabbis he does it once a month i think and i was listening to this month and he was asked that shailen he said it is because the guy who runs the business had to invest in the equipment that's necessary the shovels the snow plows whatever it is that he's using so that is so okay so i was wrong um anyway what about snowman so for two there are two parts of the question first of all is snow moxa

So the Mishnah Brewer says that rainwater is not muktza, based on the Gemara Ne'erivin, and the Shirer Shabbos therefore says, why should snow be any different?

So snow isn't muktza.

However, Rabbi Eider has in his Sefer, he quotes a footnote from Rav Moshe, and later it was a tshuva printed in the 8th volume of the Gris Moshe, that Rav Moshe holds that snow is muktza, that it's muktza machmas gufo, Rav Aaron Silver, my rabbi,

from Karim Biavena, pointed out that the footnote in Rabbi Eider Sefer, at least in the original version on snow, was footnote Shin Lamed Gimel, footnote Sheleg.

So anyway, that's what they quote from Ramosha.

I just saw Rabbi Eliezer Krohn last night at my grandnephew's bris, and he told me, because he's a Mahal, and he told me,

that he had mentioned Ramesha holds its snow is Muktsa, and someone said to him, no, you can't trust what it says in that tshuva, the 8th volume, this and that, and Ramesha holds snow is not Muktsa.

So I told him that sometimes people heard things from Rav Moshe that are against what it says in the Yigris Moshe.

Rav Moshe has a long tshuva where he explains why.

why toilet paper and tissues are not Makabal Tumah.

And I heard from Rabbi First from Chicago that he remembers Rav Moshe looking at Maros that were on toilet paper.

Sometimes it's an interesting topic of when and why Rav Moshe would go against what he writes in Negros Moshe.

But that's the first issue.

Is it Mukta?

Let's assume it's not Mukta.

Either not like Rav Moshe or maybe Rav Moshe didn't really hold that it's Mukta.

Let's assume it's not Mukta.

It's still going to be Yasser because taking...