Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
He's got a number of different dimensions.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
Can you walk us through those dimensions and how do they apply to ETH?
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
I guess just to kind of summarize where we've gone so far.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
So according to Carl Menger, the primary property of money was saleability, right?
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
Which, I mean, this concept saleability, it took me a while to understand, but one way to think about it is liquidity, I think.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
How deep the order book is almost.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
Can you sell a whole lot and not move the market at all?
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
So saleability, liquidity...
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
are somewhat in the same ballpark.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
And the most saleable good turns out to be the most money good and have the highest monetary premium.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
And Menger goes through these attributes where he's trying to say, okay, these are the attributes throughout history that have...
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
made a particular asset rise to the top in terms of its saleability.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
And you've just gone through four, scarcity, fungibility, divisibility, and portability.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
And on scarcity, you said, and by the way, your paper has this fantastic chart where it compares gold versus Bitcoin versus ETH on all of these points.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
On scarcity, you just said that Bitcoin and ETH are actually more scarce than gold, which maybe people don't realize that, but that is the case.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
Are we mining about like 1.5% to 2% of all gold supply annualized every year?
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
And Bitcoin is what I mean, that's a point eight percent issuance rate right now.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
I mean, it'll happen soon and it'll be less than that.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
And ETH is around the same.
Bankless
Productive Money: The Most Bullish Case for Ethereum ($250K) | Michael McGuiness & Vivek Raman
Is that why you rank it more scarce than gold, these two assets?