Tammy Gilden

And what we've been told is they're deeply in love. He's telling you something else.

And what we've been told is they're deeply in love. He's telling you something else.

So when Michael called her that October morning, Jennifer agreed to meet him at a Starbucks.

So when Michael called her that October morning, Jennifer agreed to meet him at a Starbucks.

They sat together at a table in the corner of the coffee shop.

They sat together at a table in the corner of the coffee shop.

She suggested a beach they could go to.

She suggested a beach they could go to.

Jennifer noticed that Michael parked far away from her and that his vehicle was caked in mud.

Jennifer noticed that Michael parked far away from her and that his vehicle was caked in mud.

She said when they arrived at the beach, she watched him fumble with things in his car. Michael suggested the two of them go for a walk. Did he seem nervous?

She said when they arrived at the beach, she watched him fumble with things in his car. Michael suggested the two of them go for a walk. Did he seem nervous?

Then, when they finished their walk, she said they each decided to stop at the bathroom before they left.

Then, when they finished their walk, she said they each decided to stop at the bathroom before they left.

Knowing that Michael could be over the top, Jennifer didn't know whether to take him seriously.

Knowing that Michael could be over the top, Jennifer didn't know whether to take him seriously.

Then Michael said something even more unsettling.

Then Michael said something even more unsettling.

After that disturbing comment, Michael got out of her car into his and drove away.

After that disturbing comment, Michael got out of her car into his and drove away.