Vincent Cunningham

One part of your new book that's already received some, let's just say, attention in the Catholic hierarchy long before publication is your investigation of the narratives of Immaculate Conception. Tell me... How this is still controversial and uncertain 2,000 years later.

One part of your new book that's already received some, let's just say, attention in the Catholic hierarchy long before publication is your investigation of the narratives of Immaculate Conception. Tell me... How this is still controversial and uncertain 2,000 years later.

Or any Joseph. Or any Joseph, yes.

Or any Joseph. Or any Joseph, yes.

Or any Joseph. Or any Joseph, yes.

How long has that been in the scholarly discussion, the possibility that Jesus might have been an illegitimate child, to use the old phrase?

How long has that been in the scholarly discussion, the possibility that Jesus might have been an illegitimate child, to use the old phrase?

How long has that been in the scholarly discussion, the possibility that Jesus might have been an illegitimate child, to use the old phrase?

In a direct way?

In a direct way?

In a direct way?

Is it an unspeakable thing among Catholic prelates and in Catholic academia to raise this question?

Is it an unspeakable thing among Catholic prelates and in Catholic academia to raise this question?

Is it an unspeakable thing among Catholic prelates and in Catholic academia to raise this question?

Who was that?

Who was that?

Who was that?

So it wasn't an entirely positive review.

So it wasn't an entirely positive review.

So it wasn't an entirely positive review.