Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing
Podcast Image

Brooke and Jeffrey

Second Date Update Classic: First Date Redate

26 Nov 2025

Transcription

Chapter 1: What happens when a caller returns for a second date update?

0.031 - 17.213 Alexis

You know, most businesses love when customers come back. When our customers come back, it means that we failed them. Yeah. We worry. Yeah, that's what it means. But we got a guy back for a second date today in your classic. You may have heard him before. So that's coming up in just a second. But let's start with your comments.

0

17.193 - 31.607 Alexis

Yeah, Rosie said, weird question, but have y'all ever done a meet and greet? I feel like that would be awesome. Love the show. We haven't done a live event in a while. We used to take listeners to Vegas. Oh, my God, you guys. It was so fun. We're going to try to bring that back.

0

32.067 - 36.712 Brooke

That was before my time. Yeah, we can't do it now that Alexis is here. Of course they stopped once I got hired.

0

36.732 - 39.134 Alexis

No, you're a liability. They didn't have a big enough budget.

0

40.155 - 40.856 Brooke

For alcohol.

40.936 - 42.718 Alexis

Yeah, exactly.

42.838 - 42.998

Exactly.

42.978 - 52.572 Alexis

All right. Well, we will get something on the books for you so that we can all meet up and hug each other. We love to meet people. Be one happy family. But if you see us in a grocery store, say hi.

52.853 - 55.917 Brooke

This is Jeff. Maybe just wave.

Chapter 2: How did Zach's previous date with Bethany go?

246.017 - 254.593 Zach

Well, I didn't open up very well. I started with, you know, hey, it's funny that... A lot of your friends are getting snatched up, and you're still single.

0

255.696 - 260.048 Alexis

Oh! Wow. You said that to her? I don't know. I think she may like it.

0

260.77 - 264.681 Zach

Yeah. I tried to stop it as it was coming out, but it didn't work.

0

264.701 - 266.305 Alexis

Oh, my gosh. What did she say back?

0

266.538 - 272.026 Zach

Well, she said something like, well, there you have it. That's why I didn't want another date with you.

273.428 - 274.71 Brooke

Ah, yeah. Just reconfirming.

275.111 - 278.195 Unknown

Well, the sparks are just flying between you two right now.

278.235 - 284.204 Brooke

The romance is getting hot. Brooke is right. Girls love being a little bit of mean. So you did get a date. How did you pivot?

284.705 - 298.939 Zach

Well, it wasn't really a date officially. It was like we... We were hanging out at the bachelorette party while I was on break, and then we were hanging out in this garden area, and we actually kind of made out a little bit.

Chapter 3: What led to Zach and Bethany's second encounter?

472.983 - 476.709 Alexis

Maybe. Just go straight for the guy. No one's going to understand that.

0

476.869 - 486.943 Jeffrey

If you remember Zach, he's a mobile bartender who met a woman named Bethany at a joint bachelor-bachelorette party he was working. Bethany said no to us the first time that we called her.

0

486.983 - 488.565 Alexis

Yeah, I mean, very clearly.

0

488.545 - 497.115 Jeffrey

But fast forward months later, they meet again at a different bachelorette party, end up making out, and now she's not texting him back.

0

497.295 - 500.739 Alexis

Okay, there's no date in any of this story. Yeah, there's really not. Let's remember that.

501.12 - 502.801 Jeffrey

Making out is pretty close.

502.821 - 507.927 Alexis

No, God no, Jess. Do you know how many dudes I've made out with that I didn't even know their names?

508.188 - 511.131 Jeffrey

It's interesting the things that you choose to brag about.

512.513 - 516.257 Alexis

I'm not bragging, I'm just saying. That's not real life what you're saying.

Chapter 4: What was the outcome of their second meeting at the bachelorette party?

611.12 - 623.431 Jeffrey

Bethany, look, I hear you. I really want to respect your wishes, but we have a job to do on this show. Just like a certain strapping hunk of a man who was doing his job serving you drinks recently at a bachelorette party.

0

623.691 - 626.147 Unknown

No. Oh, yeah. We're back.

0

626.65 - 627.911 Jeffrey

You know, Zach?

0

628.392 - 630.174 Bethany

I've been trying to forget, yes.

0

632.076 - 635.78 Brooke

Bethany! We heard the second time was way smoother than the first.

635.84 - 638.022 Bethany

No, no, guys, it was a mistake.

638.042 - 645.73 Alexis

It was a huge mistake. Wait, are you talking about the make-out session was a mistake? Yeah, obviously.

645.75 - 654.159 Jeffrey

Are you sure? Because it is interesting that the two of you keep randomly running into each other when you're at your most vulnerable, Bethany.

654.179 - 659.204 Bethany

Yeah. All of my friends keep getting married and apparently only know one bartender.

Chapter 5: Why is Bethany hesitant about dating Zach again?

880.011 - 881.563 Jeffrey

Oh, wow.

0

882.41 - 892.745 Jeff

Go for it. That loving feeling. Oh. Whoa, that loving feeling.

0

892.765 - 895.168 Unknown

All right.

0

895.188 - 898.733 Alexis

Okay. He sounds so fun. Go on one date. Come on.

0

899.313 - 903.419 Jeffrey

Yeah. We'll pay for it. Remember, Bethany, if you say yes, the date's on us.

903.479 - 924.107 Bethany

It won't be a wedding. Come on. Do it for the plot. I can't. I'm not saying that I never want to see you again, but I am going to ask If you are bartending at a bachelorette party for a girl named Sienna next month, because if you are, I'm going to have to change my RSVP.

924.268 - 924.328

No.

926.317 - 930.944 Alexis

Come on, do it for Sienna. He's a romantic at heart. What a guy.

931.124 - 934.148 Zach

I am. And I'm both solid, so there's a good chance you'll see me there.

Chapter 6: What strategies do the hosts use to encourage Bethany to reconsider?

941.358 - 945.945 Bethany

I mean, I don't know if it's him or the mojito, but...

0

945.925 - 947.928 Brooke

He may serve a strong drink.

0

947.948 - 957.363 Jeffrey

It's the perfect combo. It's all leading you towards Zach. So it might be a no from you now, Bethany, but it could be possible next month at Sienna's bachelorette party.

0

957.484 - 963.794 Alexis

Third make-out, Sag. I say third time on this show. Call back. It's going to be like 50 first dates all over again.

0

963.854 - 970.144 Jeffrey

Finally the sixth time, she goes, I'll go out with him again. We will call you 100 times until you agree to it.

970.124 - 974.574 Alexis

I think she's laughing. Not crying, right?

974.594 - 984.455 Zach

Well, you know, I think fate will lend a hand and do its thing, and I've got a good feeling we'll see each other next month. Oh, my gosh. Get your Uber app open, Bethany.

984.475 - 995.147 Jeffrey

He's going to dial it for you. Oh, my God. So, yeah, when it comes to Bethany and Zach, we are 0 for 2.

995.288 - 1000.575 Alexis

I really thought we were going to get her right there. I thought that she was like, okay, I'll give him a chance.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.